Wellington, if you read our original competition post you would note that we clearly specified we would be judging on what games we find most fun.
This whole competition is meant to just be a bit of fun, we received many more entries than we though we would! We've stuck to what we've said and run the whole thing as fairly as possible.
The community vote idea was something that was added to the competition because people said they wanted it.
We are learning a lot about competitions after running this one and will be doing it slightly differently in the future.
We are sorry if people disagree with the judging situation, but that is how it is and we can't change it. We know a lot of people put a lot of time and energy into their entries, and it really shows and is fantastic to play them all! The flip side of this is that there will be a lot of disappointed people. There's really not much we can do about that, it's a competition.