[quote:3u872tha]I think answering your question might derail the conversation and send it in a different direction, but I felt the need to add my two cents.
I guess what I was trying to say using this axe comparison is that on #1 the creativity has really taken over and the purpose is lost. This is personal opinion but, I think it is ugly as well and if you would really try to use it you would probably just hurt yourself. #2 Is more in balanced on usefulness and creativity and it is simpler as well.
If we would think just code it would be pretty much that when you have a problem you think the most complicated way first and after that realice that you could have made it much simpler and direct way. So if you think logical problem maybe a bit too creative way you might make new problems that you have to solve as well. I do this quite often on debuggin for example. Sometimes I start to look the problem from the most improbable place and later find out that it was just a small typo.
Don't know if this makes any sense to anyone anymore but, if you have a nail you have to pound it would recuire both creativity and logic to use a hammer or some type of tool instead of a barehand.
Or I could just agreed with this. That vs on the title was maybe a bit confusing.
[quote:3u872tha]The most creative solutions are often logical extrapolations, there's a fair amount of cross over.