Disabled buttons can be pressed

Post reply

❤Follow Topic(5)

0 favourites

5 posts

From the Asset Store

Game Button Sound

$10 USD

J-BoB Game Button Sound Pack comes with 300 high-quality sound effects

jbobsound

- Kyriel
- - Joined 16 Jan, 2014
  - 3 topics • 4 posts
- 1
- 16 Jun, 2014
- Quote
Problem Description

As subject says, the problem is that disabled buttons can be pressed and runs an event.

On Chrome, buttons works fine if are visible and disabled: they can't be pressed.

On Firefox and Internet Explorer, buttons can be pressed also if are visible and disabled.

Attach a Capx

https://www.dropbox.com/s/k8wsx38fv6cle ... utton.capx

Description of Capx

With this Capx you can see that pressing where there is an invisible and disabled button, an event will work anyway.

Steps to Reproduce Bug
- Run Layout
- Press where the yellow button is
Observed Result

Text "Hi" will appear also if invisible button is disabled (invisible button is on yellow area).

Expected Result

Text "Hi" should not appear because button is set on "disabled".

Affected Browsers
- Chrome: YES (only if button is invisible and disabled)
- FireFox: YES (also if button is visible and disabled)
- Internet Explorer: YES (also if button is visible and disabled)
Operating System and Service Pack

Windows 7 64 bit SP1

Construct 2 Version ID

r172
- Iolva
- - Joined 14 Jan, 2014
  - 67 topics • 690 posts
- 1
- 19 Jun, 2014
- Quote
Yep. I guess you are right.

Windows 8.1 Update 1 x64, Construct 2 R173 x64
- DUTOIT
- - Joined 17 Jul, 2013
  - 15 topics • 1,420 posts
- 1
- 19 Jun, 2014
- Quote
I don't use buttons in C2, never have - I use sprites, but I agree, it doesn't work.
Try Construct 3

Develop games in your browser. Powerful, performant & highly capable.
Try Now Construct 3 users don't see these ads
- SgtConti
- - Joined 20 Apr, 2013
  - 29 topics • 255 posts
- 1
- 19 Jun, 2014
- Quote
Totally agree on this one, but i took it more of a "It's a feature, not a bug" approach.

But while we are at it, a few additions to the Button object could be great:

Condition - If disabled

Condition - If hovered

Condition - On Right Clicked

Expression - Button State (Disabled, Enabled, Hovered)

These additions might could come in handy, at least for me

Especially the On Right Clicked and If Disabled is important for me.
- Conti
- Ashley Construct Team Founder
- Moderator
- - Joined 21 May, 2007
  - 669 topics • 30,357 posts
- 1
- 25 Jun, 2014
- Quote
Closing as not a bug. The 'Button: on clicked' trigger does not fire if the button is invisible or disabled. However you have 'Is touching button' in an OR block, and the touch object is set to use mouse input. By design, 'Is touching object' just checks if there is a touch within the object's rectangle regardless of its settings, so this is working correctly.