DUTOIT, R0j0hound, lennaert - thanks for the replies. I've tried For Each, removing the else, and a magnitude of other stuff before I posted. I did, however figure it out in case you guys were curious.
For some reason I had to switch the "Timer > 0" with the "Timer = 0". Apparently due to the "Timer = 0" event having an "Else" attached to it, it wasn't able to pick the instance, like you stated. I was, however, able to keep my Else Strange, but at least it's solved. Thanks again!