I thought that I have read somewhere on the forum, that it applies to all users, but I admit, I can be wrong.
When creating and developing a game, can easily take up several months to even more than a year if the developer have another daytime job. Up until now, I wrote small games for our little daughter. However since quit a while now, I am making plans to create an adventure game with puzzles, mazes and pitfalls. I am sure that I will use more than a year to finish my dream project.
In my opinion, the yearly subscription model is fairly priced. However, I will respect other opinions who do not agree with mine.
Look personally I'm signing up for the first year. I am in a similar position as you and need to start working on a game I actually want to finish and release.
So yeah. I just don't want to see a fragmented community since Construct has such a strong community. THis is not trivial.
A community can make a mediocre engine actually be worth investing in since people share knowledge and things are moving forward.
A monthly sub would be great, one can sign up for the first year then decide if one wants to monthly sub. If only Scirra wants to do that. I don't see why not if they are willing to offer that for Educational institutions.
Seems this option is what most want and it doesn't change Scirra's business model or revenue stream. In fact people who want to sign up for a year would still do that, now instead of losing the user at least the user will pay for a month or two before deciding if he wants to continue or go elsewhere.
There will be a big brain/talent drain to other engines imho if there are limited options. Business 101 - Don't make it difficult for people to give you money.
Unfortunately there are the ones that's completely against it but....Scirra can even please them by what Ashley proposed as looking into (Opening projects etc from previous versions if you used it for a project) imho this coupled with the yearly and monthly options will only then lose the people that really are against subscriptions on principle.
Anycase, the poll is just an attempt for me to see what the users really want seeing as nothing like that was ever done from what I know. (Im not a regular forumite...well I am now since I'm starting to use C3)