OKAY, so I found a way to remove the stuttering!!
I read online that windows explore may be affecting the rendering, so I changed my windows theme to Classic, and now my game runs super smooth!
Apparently the custom theme requires more processing, so it must have been affecting the rendering in some way.
Newer versions of windows deal with it better, but since I use an old version of windows, the stuttering is insane. Changing my theme to Classic removes all the stutter.
If you're experiencing stutter, you should try changing your theme to Classic to see if it improves it!