FIXED (It was an Oversight) - Replace Color not working properly

I have about 30 'CollectionGradeLevel' Sprites already laid out in my Layout, and I want them to change color depending on what rarity they are, in order to cut down and the amount of animations I need to have in the game.

Now, it picks everything correctly, but only replaces the color for the last few sprites, and even then it doesn't replace all of the colors but only some.

Any idea what could be causing this?

FIXED: I missed setting the Source color for some of the Sprites, and the Effects were named wrong: It was ReplaceColor, ReplaceColor2, ReplaceColor3, ReplaceColor4, and thats why it didn't pick it correctly.